Skip to main content

Ohio College Savings (529) Plan to add Dimensional Funds


On March 3rd, the Ohio 529 Board announced changes to the college savings program fund lineup. The Board announced, "Based on extensive research, Dimensional was recommended because it offers relatively low-cost options and has many products that are ranked highly by OTTA’s investment consultant, Wilshire Associates, Inc."

This is great news for Ohio 529 plan participants. Dimensional Funds have a strong, empirical underpinning and have long been a core component of the True Wealth Design investment portfolios. For participants that well-utilize their funds, this should help provide more dollars on a tax-free basis for qualified higher education expenses.

To Your Prosperity,

Kevin Kroskey, CFP® MBA

 
Click here for the full news release from the Ohio 529 Board.

 
Click here for cover story from Baron's “A Different Dimension” for more information on Dimensional Funds and what makes them different. Selected highlights are below:

DIMENSIONAL'S FUNDS aim to capture the returns of an asset class -- be it small or large companies, developed or emerging markets -- without slavishly adhering to an index. And they do. For example, take the Vanguard Small Cap Value index fund (VISVX), which is based on the S&P 600 Small Cap Value index and is the counterpart toDimensional's DFA US Small Cap Value (DFSVX). The DFA fund has a much smaller tilt -- its average market value is $1.1 billion, versus Vanguard's $2.7 billion -- and on all measures is much more value-oriented. So the Dimensional fund better captures the market-beating advantage of small and value stocks. In fact, a lot better: The DFA fund returned 42% in 2013, beating 88% of its peers in Morningstar's small-cap value category, versus the Vanguard fund's 36% return, which beat just 53%. Over 15 years, which includes periods that were less favorable to small and/or value stocks, DFA's fund returned an average of 12% a year, beating 80% of peers. The Vanguard fund returned 10% on average, beating just 37% of peers.

The Dimensional fund costs twice as much as Vanguard's -- 0.52% versus 0.24% -- but the significant outperformance more than makes up for that difference.

TRADING IS ALSO a crucial factor in DFA's outperformance. Index funds trade in baskets -- whenever a stock is added or dropped from the index, it's bought or sold almost immediately, which can drive the price up or down. Similarly, active managers often want to get into or out of a stock quickly. DFA, however, takes a more methodical, opportunistic approach to trading. There's never pressure to buy or sell a fund within a certain time frame. Instead, it serves as a market-maker for the 14,000 stocks it owns, offering to sell when frenzied buying has sent the bid higher, and taking a stock off another trader's hands when the shares can be acquired cheaply. Every morning, traders get a list of stocks the firm wants to buy or sell, but instead of mandated trading orders, the trading desk determines if conditions are good for each transaction. "We go into the market and see where the most anxiety is and where we can trade at favorable prices," says Booth. "We provide liquidity."

Trade execution is critical to another factor that Fama and French added to their model more recently: Stocks that are falling tend to continue to fall, and those that are rising tend to continue to rise. "So you want to trade slowly," Booth says. "We are slow to trade most of the new names that have recently fallen into the value category, because they are negative-momentum stocks. We're also slow to sell positive-momentum stocks. We'll hold on for years."

Trading costs have also influenced portfolio construction, as have the sharp advisors that work with the firm. Dimensional's 5,000-stock international core funds, for instance, were created at the behest of the firm's largest client, $22 billion Buckingham Asset Management. The international core fund combines developed and emerging markets, minimizing the trading costs that would occur, say, when a country like Israel or South Korea "graduates" from the emerging to the developed category. Rather than one fund selling and another buying, advisors who want exposure to both asset classes can get it in one fund. "That eliminates risk and costs, and we don't have to rebalance," says Larry Swedroe, a principal at Buckingham. "That's a huge advantage, and a big innovation." Dimensional also has a 3,000-stock U.S. core fund.

Dimensional has 76 funds, many of which overlap because of its willingness to work with advisors to meet their needs. "We have several versions of our core portfolios to accommodate advisors who want more or less of a small or value tilt," Repetto says.

The latest factor, profitability, has been steadily implemented since being introduced in four funds a year ago; it will be a factor in all DFA funds by early this year. The profitability factor incorporates firms with higher profitability relative to price, cash flow, or other metrics. That's essentially the secret behind Warren Buffett's success. Investors tend to pay too much for -- or, in other words, not apply enough of a risk discount to -- "lottery" stocks. Think of a bell curve of stock returns: You'll see far more returns to the left of the mean, and a few outsize winners on the right. That market's willingness to pay for the small chance of outsize gains means that other profitable firms, relatively speaking, have lower prices.

Popular posts from this blog

Don't File Your Taxes Too Soon

I'd like to remind everyone to not be too anxious to file your taxes. Many taxpayers rush to file their tax returns as quickly as possible. Ordinarily, that’s fine. But if you own mutual funds, don’t file your tax return before March 1. In past years, revised 1099s were often issued, reclassifying distributions and/or their amounts. This was a huge headache for the investors who had already filed tax returns based on the original documentation. These hapless consumers found themselves forced to redo their returns and file amended tax returns, adjusting the amount they owed or were due in refunds - and paying their tax preparer additional fees to do the extra work. It looks like 2010 may be the same. Therefore, if you own mutual funds, do not file your tax return before March 1. By then, any amended IRS forms are likely to arrive, potentially helping you avoid the hassle and costs of filing an amended return. Kevin Kroskey, CFP, MBA

Bangladesh Butter Production Predicts U.S. Stock Returns

After reading the title of this post, my hope is that a look of disbelief is cast on your face. Of course butter production in Bangladesh has nothing to do with prediction of US stock market returns. However, through data mining all sorts of 'relationships' can be demonstrated. Many mutual funds, ETFs, and trading strategies are built upon these data mining strategies--most often to the harm of investors that utilize them. As Jason Zweig describes in a recent article in the Wall Street Journal, entitled Data Mining Isn't a Good Bet For Stock-Market Predictions , "The stock market generates such vast quantities of information that, if you plow through enough of it for long enough, you can always find some relationship that appears to generate spectacular returns -- by coincidence alone . This sham is known as data mining." I recall in from my business statistics course in grad school, how I was able to show that ice cream consumption was correlated to the murder ra

Paying for College and Getting Your Money's Worth

According to the Student Loan Marketing Association (more commonly known as Sallie Mae Bank), the average tuition, room and board at a private college comes to $43,921. Public tuition for in-state students at state colleges amounted to $19,548 (about half of which is room and board), with out-of-state students paying an average of $34,031. How are parents and students finding the cash to afford this expense? Sallie Mae breaks it down as follows: 34% from scholarships and grants that don’t have to be paid back, coming from the college itself or the state or federal government, often based on need and academic performance. Parents typically pay 29% of the total bill (an average of $7,000) out of savings or income, and other family members (think: grandparents) are paying another 5%. The students themselves are paying for 12% of the cost, on average. The rest, roughly 20% of the total, is made up of loans.  The federal government’s loan program offers up to $5,500 a year fo